This unisex gourmand perfectly captures autumn’s embrace – but is Poesie’s latest rice pudding creation worth the premium price?
When Demeter launched as part of Poesie’s “Persephone Crowned” fall 2025 collection, it immediately sparked debate among indie fragrance enthusiasts. Featuring rosy red apples baked with apple pie spices, cinnamon sticks, creamy vanilla-infused rice pudding, and crème brûlée, this unisex gourmand promised something special for autumn. After testing this atmospheric scent, here’s the complete story.
Opening: Spiced Apple Perfection
Demeter opens with what one reviewer perfectly described as “crunchy red apple (I perceive it more as fresh than baked)” layered with warm apple pie spices. The cinnamon is prominent but never overwhelming – it’s the perfect dusting rather than craft-store intensity. The apple feels genuinely fresh and crisp, avoiding the artificial candy-sweetness that plagues many apple fragrances.
One enthusiast noted: “The combination of crunchy red apple and the cozy creaminess feels incredibly autumnal.”
The Heart: Rice Pudding Magic
As Demeter develops, Poesie’s signature rice pudding emerges beautifully. This isn’t the heavy, starchy rice note many fear – instead, it creates what reviewers describe as “more vanilla and a tonka-like caramel effect” from the crème brûlée topping. The rice pudding provides creamy texture without feeling dense or cloying.
The vanilla infusion adds sophistication, while the pie spices (heavy on cinnamon) create that perfect autumn comfort feeling.
The Dry Down: Sweet Simplicity
After several hours, Demeter settles into what one reviewer called “vague apple sweetness.” The complexity of the opening gives way to a simpler, sweeter composition that stays close to the skin. Some find this disappointing, while others appreciate the gentle, comforting drydown.
The crème brûlée aspect becomes more pronounced, adding caramelized sugar notes that prevent it from becoming too one-dimensional.
Performance: Moderate but Fleeting
Multiple reviewers note that Demeter fades quickly, transforming significantly after just a few hours. The projection is moderate initially, then becomes quite intimate. Longevity averages 4-6 hours on most skin types, which is typical for Poesie’s gourmands.
Note: This is definitely a “reapplication needed” fragrance for all-day wear.
The Unisex Appeal
Despite being a sweet gourmand, Demeter works well across gender lines. The apple and spice elements prevent it from feeling overly feminine, while the rice pudding adds comfort without being cloying. It’s “incredibly autumnal” in the best way – cozy rather than saccharine.
Who Should Try This?
Perfect for:
- Lovers of realistic apple fragrances (not candy-sweet)
- Fans of Poesie’s rice pudding scents
- Those seeking comfortable, cozy autumn scents
- Anyone wanting a non-traditional gourmand
Skip if:
- You prefer strong projection and longevity
- Sweet/gourmand fragrances overwhelm you
- You want something bold and statement-making
- The premium pricing feels unjustified
Price and Value
Pricing:
- 5ml – $5.50
- Sample: Available through decant circles
Note: Poesie has implemented significant price increases recently, making this a considered purchase rather than an impulse buy.
Demeter Delivers Autumn Magic
This fragrance succeeds brilliantly at capturing the essence of fall comfort. The apple and spice combination feels genuine and sophisticated, while the rice pudding adds unique texture that sets it apart from typical autumn gourmands.
One reviewer who typically avoids gourmands said: “If someone like me, who generally avoids gourmands, enjoys this scent, I can easily see it becoming a favorite among many.”
The craftsmanship is evident – Poesie’s rice pudding work is consistently excellent, and their ability to create “anti-cozy gourmands” shines through.
Rating: 4/5
If you love sophisticated apple fragrances and unique gourmand textures, Demeter delivers exactly what its mythological name promises – the essence of harvest abundance. Just be prepared for moderate longevity and consider stocking up if it becomes a favorite.
Available now as part of Poesie’s limited “Persephone Crowned” fall collection.
