The internet’s favorite blue fragrance returns in extrait form – but is the deeper, floral-forward version worth the premium?
When Blue Talisman Extrait launched in September 2025, it had big shoes to fill. The original Blue Talisman became one of the most talked-about fragrances in recent years, spawning countless reviews, dupes, and debates. Now Ex Nihilo has cranked up the concentration to extrait levels – but does it improve on perfection or mess with a winning formula?
First Impressions: Floral Forward
The most striking difference hits you immediately – Blue Talisman Extrait leads with florals, not citrus. While the original opens with bright bergamot and crisp pear, the extrait version pushes jasmine sambac and orange blossom right to the forefront, creating what one reviewer called “a sweet white floral combination.
The pear and bergamot are still there, but they’re supporting players now. This makes the extrait feel significantly more unisex from the start, which explains why many female fragrance enthusiasts have gravitated toward this version.
The Heart: Orange Blossom Dominance
About 90 minutes in, orange blossom takes complete control. This isn’t subtle – it’s potent, solar, and enveloping. The Ambrofix™ that made the original so distinctive is still present, but it’s wrapped in creamy florals that completely change the fragrance’s personality.
As one fragrance YouTuber noted: “Orange blossom has that sweetness that eventually develops into the ambery notes… it’s all orange blossom for hours.”
The Dry Down: Familiar Territory
Here’s where Blue Talisman Extrait starts feeling like its predecessor. The vanilla, sandalwood, and amber woods create that signature musky, aquatic quality that made the original addictive. The Iso E Super and ambroxan combination delivers that “room-filling” presence Ex Nihilo is known for.
The woody base is noticeably richer and more textured than the original, justifying the extrait designation.
Performance: Nuclear Strength
This is where the extrait truly shines. Multiple reviewers report 12-14 hours of longevity with substantial projection for the first 6 hours. One tester noted it was still detectable “after a shower.”
Fair warning: This is room-filling strength. Two sprays maximum – you’ve been warned.
The Big Question: Original vs Extrait?
Here’s where it gets interesting. These fragrances share about 90% of their DNA, but that 10% difference is significant:
Choose Original if:
- You want fresh, citrusy versatility
- You prefer more “masculine” blue fragrances
- You like the bright, summery vibe
- You want better value for money
Choose Extrait if:
- You love prominent white florals
- You prefer unisex fragrances
- You want maximum longevity
- You’re willing to pay for luxury concentration
Price and Value
UK Pricing:
- 50ml: £185
- 100ml: £295
The price jump over the original EDP (£165 for 100ml) is substantial. You’re paying premium money for that 30% extrait concentration and enhanced performance.
Blue Talisman Extrait Shifts the Game
This isn’t simply a “stronger” version of the original – it’s a different interpretation entirely. The floral-forward opening and orange blossom dominance create a fragrance that’s more unisex, more luxurious, and frankly, more sophisticated.
While some may miss the fresh versatility of the original, the extrait succeeds in creating something genuinely premium. The performance is exceptional, the craftsmanship is evident, and the white florals add complexity that keeps you coming back.
Rating: 4/5
If you loved Blue Talisman but wanted something richer and more unisex, the extrait delivers brilliantly. Just don’t expect a carbon copy – this is Blue Talisman reimagined for those who prefer depth over brightness.
Available now at Ex Nihilo boutiques, department stores, and select niche fragrance retailers worldwide.
